+R.I.P. Adreinne Asch

Photo of Adrienne Asch from National Federation for the Blind website disability rights abortion

Adrienne Asch

Disability rights activist Adrienne Asch passed away last week, only 67 years old.

Asch was always an enigmatic figure to me.  Among the disability rights activists, she was particularly strong in her opposition to the abortion of children with disabilities, and to prenatal testing to screen out those children.  And yes, she did use the language of “children” to refer to the unborn babies with disabilities.

In spite of this, Asch was also a strong proponent of women’s right to abortion. She made a distinction between a mother who didn’t want to be pregnant and one who did not want a disabled child:

In the first case, her colleague Professor Kittay explained, “you’re not seeking to abort ‘this particular child.’ ” In the second, she said, “when you’re seeking to abort because of disability, it’s not ‘any potential child,’ it’s this child, with these particular characteristics.”

To my thinking, both scenarios locate the child’s value in the mother’s appraisal, not in the inherent worth of the child.  That external valuation is the central reality against which Ms. Asch was so active.  She presented her own blindness as just one aspect of life, one that should not marginalize her, nor be a reason for aborting children who share her disability. 

In spite of this paradox in her thinking, I appreciated her strong stance: “Life with disability is worthwhile and  the belief that a just society must appreciate and nurture the lives of all people.” (AmJPubHealth 1999)


In Memoriam, Adrienne Asch from Yeshiva University

Asch, A. (1999). Prenatal diagnosis and selective abortion: A challenge to practice and policy. American Journal of Public Health89(11), 1649-1657. Retrieved from http://beck2.med.harvard.edu/week8/asch.pdf

About Sister Edith

Benedictine sister of St. Scholastica Monastery, Duluth, Minnesota
This entry was posted in Life Issues, People. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are welcome and moderated

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s